On New Year's Eve, Craig LaBan walked into Pine Street Grill alone with no reservation and took an open seat at the bar. In his Philadelphia Inquirer review he described what followed: a pint of Guinness, matzo ball soup, a double-decker burger with Cooper Sharp, and a run of bar-stool conversations. When the diner next to him left, someone new took the seat almost right away.
That scene says a lot about how the square works this time of year. On the blocks around 23rd and Pine, most of the good things this winter reward the neighbor who just walks over. The corner restaurant holds back part of its room for people who don't book. The Saturday market keeps going after other markets close for the season. The park's holiday lightings happen once, with no rain date. If you're there, you're in.
Half the corner room is held for whoever walks in
Pine Street Grill opened in December 2025 at 2227 Pine St., in the corner space overlooking the square that many neighbors still remember as Dmitri's. Chefs Amanda Shulman and Alex Kemp also run Her Place Supper Club and My Loup. They built this one as an everyday neighborhood restaurant, with American comfort food, a full bar, weekend brunch, and a children's menu.
Reservations at the couple's restaurants are famously hard to get. At Pine Street Grill, LaBan reported that at least half of the 58 seats are set aside for walk-ins. The restaurant's own FAQ still says half the dining room is reserved for walk-ins. In LaBan's experience, waits were reasonable on midweek evenings before 7 p.m. Prime time could bring two-hour waits.
So if you're walking over, timing matters more than booking. These are the hours on the restaurant's location page:
- Monday, Wednesday, Thursday: dinner 4 to 10 p.m.
- Tuesday: closed
- Friday: dinner 4 to 11 p.m.
- Saturday: brunch 10:30 a.m. to 2 p.m., dinner 5 to 11 p.m.
- Sunday: brunch 10:30 a.m. to 2 p.m., dinner 5 to 10 p.m.
These hours have changed since the spring review, which listed a 10 a.m. brunch start and 11 p.m. closings on more nights. Go by the restaurant's page, and plan on brunch's last seating at 1:30 p.m.
The menu nods to the old Dmitri's on purpose. The shrimp pil pil starts from the old recipe, with bigger shrimp and a saucier, more buttery finish. The current online dinner menu lists it at $26, next to a $23 PSG burger, a $26 fat eggplant parm, and a $36 roasted chicken. Families can order from Belle's Bites, for kids 10 and under, where tenders and fries, a kids' burger, a quesadilla, and noodles are each $10.
The brunch windows look out on a market that stays open all winter
The best part of LaBan's review may be the view. He described weekend brunch with "sunshine pouring in through windows framing the lively farmers market on Fitler Square."
That market runs Saturdays from 9 a.m. to noon at 23rd and Pine, operated by Brogue Hydroponics. The Food Trust lists it as a partner market, separate from the three year-round markets it runs itself. Brogue says the Fitler market is outdoors and year-round, weather permitting. Philadelphia preorders can be picked up every Saturday, all year. Brogue sells its own hydroponic and organic produce along with local cheeses.
Put the two schedules side by side and they fit neatly. The market closes at noon, and Pine Street Grill starts seating brunch at 10:30 a.m. You can shop the square and then sit down across the street, with no reservation at either stop. The current brunch menu includes a $17 beef-salami-and-egg sandwich, $16 shrimp and grits, and a $14 cocoa spelt waffle. LaBan called the spelt waffles, crisped in the Belgian Liège style, a dessert worth ordering twice.
An earlier start on 22nd Street
The day can start before the market opens. La Maison Jaune, at 244 S. 22nd St., is a French cafe that the Inquirer covered in December 2025, about four weeks after it opened. The menu at the time included macarons de Nancy, financiers, madeleines, quiche, matcha, and Rival Bros. coffee. That report listed hours of 7 a.m. to 4 p.m. Monday through Thursday and 7 a.m. to 5 p.m. Friday through Sunday. Those are opening-season hours, so check the cafe's website before an early walk.
The park's holiday lightings have no rain dates
The Fitler Square Park events page lists three upcoming events. The page doesn't print a year, but the weekdays it gives match the 2026 calendar. Neither lighting has a rain date, so each one happens once.
| Event | Date | Time | Rain date |
|---|---|---|---|
| Love Your Park Day of Service | Saturday, November 14 | 10 a.m. to noon | Not listed |
| Christmas Tree Lighting | Sunday, December 6 | 4 to 5 p.m. | None |
| Menorah Lighting | Monday, December 7 | 5 p.m. | None |
A PhillyFamily guide to holiday tree lightings published in late October lists the Fitler Square lighting for December 6, 2026, at 4 p.m. It says Santa, hot drinks, and carols are planned.
The park's page asks anyone who wants to volunteer at these events to email [email protected].
November 14 is the one day this season when every piece around the square lines up. The schedule below uses only posted hours:
- 7 a.m. La Maison Jaune's listed weekend opening on 22nd Street, if those hours still hold.
- 9 a.m. The Brogue Hydroponics market opens at 23rd and Pine.
- 10 a.m. to noon Love Your Park Day of Service in the square.
- By 1:30 p.m. Last brunch seating at Pine Street Grill, with half the room set aside for walk-ins.
The two lightings are closer to dinner time. The tree lighting ends at 5 p.m. on Sunday, December 6, which is when Pine Street Grill starts Sunday dinner service. The Menorah Lighting on Monday, December 7, starts at 5 p.m., an hour after the restaurant opens for Monday dinner. Both fall in the early-evening window LaBan found best for walking in.
The same chefs signed for another corner within walking distance
Shulman and Kemp aren't stopping at Pine Street. On October 22, the Inquirer reported that the couple filed a liquor license application for a new restaurant at 1736 Spruce St. That's the southeast corner of 18th and Spruce, home to Barclay Pharmacy until it closed in 2023 after more than eight decades. Shulman confirmed the lease to the paper. "We're still figuring out the details of what it will become," she said. No concept or opening date has been announced.
The building is a mid-19th-century Italianate townhouse, and its facade is under scaffolding for now. The location fits a pattern the couple has described before. When they signed the lease at 23rd and Pine, Shulman told the Inquirer it was "all part of our master plan to be able to keep our commute to a 15-minute walk, max."
On the square itself, the next dates are the Day of Service on Saturday, November 14, at 10 a.m., the tree lighting on Sunday, December 6, at 4 p.m., and the menorah lighting on Monday, December 7, at 5 p.m.
If you want to talk through which Fitler Square blocks put the market, Pine Street Grill, and the holiday lightings closest to your front door, the O'Donnell Coyle Realty Team is happy to walk the square with you. Reach out and tell us how you like to spend a Saturday morning.