Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. I will be in touch with you shortly.

The Art of Showing Up for a Stranger You Met on an App

The Art of Showing Up for a Stranger You Met on an App

I’m not sure what’s been in the air in Philadelphia lately, but I’ve now attended my second “stranger dinner” of the year- something a past version of me would’ve overthought into an immediate absolutely not.

In case you were ever wondering, "What does a logical boyfriend do when his girlfriend moves to a new city and says she wants to meet people?" Apparently, he builds an app.

That’s essentially how The Collective came to life. Its founder, Warren, saw firsthand how hard it was for his girlfriend to make friends after moving here- a situation that feels painfully familiar to a lot of adults. Long workdays, the same coworkers, routines on repeat, and weekends filled with the same trusted circle. Making new friends isn’t impossible, but it definitely doesn’t happen as effortlessly as it did when we were all forced into socialization via school cafeterias and extracurriculars.

I like to think I’m outgoing, but not quite at the level of casually asking someone for their details after one good conversation. Unless buying, selling, or renting comes up- then suddenly real estate takes the wheel and I’m incredibly proactive.

Still, I genuinely like meeting new people. I’m nosy in the socially acceptable way when it's someone I'd like to learn more about- I want to know what people are into, where they spend their Sundays, and which places or streets in the city feel like home to them.

I found The Collective on TikTok and joined during its trial phase. The concept is simple, but the execution feels different. There’s no swiping, no endless passive lurking. You actually have to send a message. Revolutionary, I know.

That tiny bit of effort changes everything. It forces you to slow down, read someone’s profile, and find an actual starting point instead of reducing people to a two second vibe check.

The app also has threads for everything from bar crawls and fitness classes to gatekept work from home spots and events to hear great live music. It’s built specifically for women, and it feels intentional in a way most social apps don’t.

Sure, I’ve met plenty of people organically before, friends of friends, nights out, neighbors that run the same routine, random conversations that somehow become memorable. But there’s something oddly refreshing about intentionally choosing to connect with someone first. It adds a layer of curiosity that feels different.

That’s what made this dinner stand out.

Warren hosted a giveaway through the app: a $350 dinner in Rittenhouse. The location? Borromini! Conveniently one of my current hyperfixations for the vibe, menu, and the fact that it’s close enough to justify ending up there with alarming frequency.

I entered casually, but I’ll admit there was a small, irrationally confident part of me that thought, I actually might win this.

Manifestation? Delusion? Strong intuition? Who’s to say.

Then I got the message that I’d be meeting someone I had absolutely no ties to other than the fact that we had both downloaded the app.

I was paired with Elyshia, and by the end of the night, we walked out as actual friends- not in the vague “we should do this again sometime” way, but in the kind of way where conversation feels easy and you’re already making plans before the night is over. I even invited her to my Cinco de Mayo plans the following week without a second thought. We ended up leaving Borromini after chatting over martinis and amazing italian for over two hours.

It felt natural in the best way. This whole experience felt like a small reminder of something obvious but easy to forget: saying yes a little more often tends to make life more interesting.

Not in a chaotic, overbooked, burn yourself out kind of way. But in small, intentional ways. The kind that slowly expand your life.

At the start of this year, I made a quiet decision to be a little less rigid. To stop overanalyzing every unfamiliar opportunity into an eh, maybe. To be more open to things that initially feel outside my routine.

So far, it’s been worth it.

It’s brought genuinely good people into my life- new friends for spontaneous weeknight dinners, other couples to watch the Phillies with, checking out new spots I wouldn't have without being invited, and even joining a soccer league that started as a casual suggestion and somehow is now a highlight of my week.

Turns out unfamiliar doesn’t automatically mean wrong. Sometimes it just means new.

Lately I’ve been focusing more on just making a choice and then forcing it to be a good one. That mindset shift alone has brought a noticeably better energy into my life. Which leads me to: go meet the random stranger you met on an app! 

There’s also something to be said for priorities. Some things are flexible- emails, work, schedules. They bend. They recover. But relationships, people who make our lives better, are a little less forgiving.

Those are the worthwhile investments. And, connection definitely falls somewhere near the top of that list.

Cities like Philadelphia can feel repetitive when routine takes over. But they’re also full of people you haven’t met yet and experiences that don’t fit neatly into your usual plans.

Sometimes it just comes down to showing up- where you end up meeting someone who automatically makes your life brighter and genuinely deserves a place in it.

This wasn’t just about winning a dinner or meeting a remarkable + accomplished OG Philadelphian. It was a reminder that meaningful connection is still very much out there, you just have to be open enough to find it.
 
If you want to meet and connect with amazing women in the city, or even enter in to the second stranger dinner raffle- download or follow The Collective.

Ready To Make Your Next Move?

Whether you're buying, selling, or just exploring your options, The O'Donnell Coyle Realty Team powered by RE/MAX is here to guide you every step of the way. Reach out today and let’s turn your real estate goals into reality.

Follow Me on Instagram